The Dow has struck one of my targets

Nov 16, 2012, 04:15

Share with
friends:

Comments (8)

In recent days, I have been swinging between covering gold and the Dow – and ignoring the euro. This is because I really have nothing new to say about the euro – the market has been working lower for a month now towards my major target as the US dollar has been gaining strength (contrary to much learned opinion, please note).

But action in the Dow has been anything but normal. In Monday’s post, this was the picture:

Dow Jones spread betting chart

(Click on the chart for a larger version)

The critical 13,000 support level had been decisively broken – and that alone would have been a great reason to take a short trade.

And this week, the market has dropped back down to my lower tramline.

I had expected at least a partial bounce back to try for the underside of the 13,000 pink zone. But Mr Market was in full flight down and since I believe we are in a very large third wave – and these are generally relentless in their thrust – this was totally in keeping with my interpretation.

Why I’m breaking my own rule

Dow spread betting chart

(Click on the chart for a larger version)

On Wednesday, the market moved sharply lower and broke below my lower tramline. 

Now, this tramline is not terribly secure because it has few touch points, especially in recent trading (only one!). I may have to adjust its position.

Not only that, but my upper line only sports two touch points – also not a terribly secure line. I would have preferred at least three.

I am not relying on these too much until I see more chart work. That is why I am not yet taking my short trade off the table, as is my rule for when the market hits – or overshoots – the lower tramline.

Has anyone noticed the Dow dip?

I have a short swing trade working from the 13,250 area and I will need more evidence to give me a reason to take profits. Where can that come from?

Here is the updated daily chart showing the Fibonacci retraces:

Dow spread betting chart

(Click on the chart for a larger version)

I have taken the October 2011 low as my low pivot point, and observe how the 4 June low lies exactly on the Fibonacci 50% level – and that was before the recent highs were put in! I see this phenomenon frequently – and when I do, it gives me confidence in the targets I derive from these Fibonacci levels.


MoneyWeek Trader logo

Claim your FREE report: The six-step game-plan for
spread betting profits


Trade tip: Look out for these events, which can occur in any time frame.

The market is heading for the 38% level (pink zone) at the 12,450 area.

There is one thing I currently find remarkable: I have scanned the media and cannot find a reference to the fact that the Dow has lost over 1,000 points in about a month. Am I the only person to have noticed?

And this brings up the question of sentiment. In the media at least, there is little discomfort at this large “dip”.

I have recently written about sudden changes of sentiment with my frozen pond story. My question is: has the bullish sentiment suddenly reversed?

To help answer this, I turn to the VIX measure of fear:

Vix chart

(Source: Yahoo! Finance - Click on the chart for a larger version)

Even with this 1,000-point ‘dip’, the VIX is only just getting up off the floor (where it was on the summer rally). A low reading indicates complacency and a high one indicates panic (usually a selling panic as in October 2011!).

All of this is telling me that there is little fear of a major rout out there.

Could there be a major sentiment change?

But is the market ripe for a major change in trend? Here is the latest committments of traders (COT) data:

Non-commercialCommercialTotalNon-reportable positions
LongShortSpreadsLongShortLongShortLongShort
OPEN INTEREST: 51,112
COMMITMENTS
14,735 6,462 1,859 26,955 38,500 43,549 46,820 7,564 4,293
CHANGES FROM 30/10/12 (CHANGE IN OPEN INTEREST: -2,725)
-1,737 -2,226 769 -894 -1,467 -1,862 -2,924 -863 199
PERCENT OF OPEN INTEREST FOR EACH CATEGORY OF TRADERS
28.8 12.6 3.6 52.7 75.3 85.2 91.6 14.8 8.4
NUMBER OF TRADERS IN EACH CATEGORY (TOTAL TRADERS: 92)
26 14 6 36 27 65 44

The large speculators (aka hedge funds) are still better than two-to-one long, while the small speculators are almost two-to-one long. The changes in the week are interesting. The hedgies reduced their longs (expected in a decline), but also reduced their shorts by a massive 25% - just before this week’s big swoon!

That’s called timing – very bad timing. But the little guys are getting it right – they reduced their longs and increased their shorts.

Because of the small sample size, I cannot take this data too seriously, but I believe it adds to the case for a major sentiment change, which is also supported by the latest AAII data. Remember, this is a survey of US 'mom and pop investors' who are more likely to be in the trenches of the real economy than hedge fund managers:

W/e 14 NovChange in weekLong-term average
Bullish 29% -10% 39%
Bearish 49% +9% 30%
Neutral 22% +1% 31%

I find these numbers staggering. There has been a weekly swing of almost 20% to the bearish cause. Maybe they have noticed the 1000-point Dow ‘dip’ too.

The other fascinating point is that the neutrals are only at 22% - a full 9% below the long-term average. This is getting into record low territory I believe, and surely indicates that the markets are getting even more polarised – as is the entire world. 

Last time, I had a possible Elliott wave picture for this move down. I may have to make a major adjustment for the wave 1 low!

• If you’re a new reader, or need a reminder about some of the methods I refer to in my trades, then do have a look at my introductory videos:

The essentials of tramline trading
Advanced tramline trading
An introduction to Elliott wave theory
Advanced trading with Elliott waves
Trading with Fibonacci levels
Trading with 'momentum'
Putting it all together

• Don't miss my next trading insight. To receive all my spread betting blog posts by email, as soon as I've written them, just sign up here . If you have any queries regarding MoneyWeek Trader, please contact us here.

Comments (8)

Share with
friends:

Comments

  • 1. Joe

    (16 November 2012, 04:48PM)  Complain about this comment

    Good call John. I've been following this one and it's been unfolding just as you suggested. It's remarkable how accurate your assessments can be sometimes!

    Could you let me know when the DVD set teaching your methods will be ready? They seem to have been a long time coming and I really want to get watching them!

    thanks and have a good weekend.

    JV

  • 2. SH

    (16 November 2012, 07:01PM)  Complain about this comment

    Hi John,

    You have been very insightful with your pointed analysis. I am not clear with your ending note..are you looking for a further downside or expecting a bounce back? Pls. let me know.

    Thanks

    SH

  • 3. Paul Wilkin

    (17 November 2012, 02:44PM)  Complain about this comment

    Thank you for another excellent analysis and profit, though like SH I am a little confused. You previously suggested a kiss of the 13000 tramline before a wave down to 12000. This downtrend seemed to meet resistance at 12450 and be heading back up. Are you expecting it to continue towards 13000 then go down to 12000 or is what has happened an update of that scenario?

  • 4. Phil

    (18 November 2012, 07:27AM)  Complain about this comment

    Anybody know of any decent charting software? I have been using a particular spread betting provider but, after the latest fiasco with the update to their charts over the weekend, i need something more reliable. Thanks

  • 5. Keith

    (18 November 2012, 06:30PM)  Complain about this comment

    To Phil,
    There are loads of free charts here http://www.dailyfx.com/charts/forexpowerchart/. Apart from Power Charts, there are a few other free chart packages on www.dailyfx.com. With Power Charts you can set up and save up to 20 different instruments that seem to include all that John covers. After calling up the website just click on the instruments tab to see what's available. On the top right of the chart, there's a "pin" shape next to a flashing green blob, to expand it across the screen. A full tutorial can be found at www.netdania.com. I've been using these charts for over 5 years, they are very good.

  • 6. Zhivko Yordanov

    (18 November 2012, 07:35PM)  Complain about this comment

    Dear John,
    What kind of nonsense is that? Why did you change yor "tramline"?
    First you draw the support line via one of the 1300 bottoms near 25.Oct., then you change your mind and draw it lower .
    I bet you have no idea when to take profits and/or open a long position.
    If you had opened long position on the double bottom at 13000, it would have been nice little profit and later after two pullbacks we can see how it breaks the uptrend and starts a new downtrend.
    Isn't it better to play it on shorter trends than a big channel?

    Kind Regars

  • 7. Bronco Bill

    (18 November 2012, 10:42PM)  Complain about this comment

    Some technical indicators for the Dow (and S&P) are now in "extreme" oversold territory.
    At the moment the charts look to be gearing up for the usual Santa Claus end of year rally- but with all whats going on in the world at this moment, anything can happen, and probably will. With reference to the VIX John. I have an interest in this as I trade the "VXX" S&P ETF.
    On the daily chart the bars have been in a tight 5 point range within 21 day Bollinger Bands since beginning October. The Dow is a 1000 points down and the S&P over 100 and yet the VIX has not as you say John reflected this. Is Mr Market going to spring a surprise ?
    Is this the calm before a storm really hits - those B Bands are not going to stay tight forever ?

  • 8. Niru Devani

    (20 November 2012, 04:22PM)  Complain about this comment


    Hello John,

    Could you please cover NDX and Apple next time? Thanks.

    I would definitely subscribe if you chose to launch a service giving 'live' trade ideas. By the time I get your email, often the best entry point has gone. I do use your methodology in my trading.

Leave a comment

This will be the name displayed with your comment.

This helps us verify comments are genuine. It will not be displayed anywhere on the site and is stored confidentially.

Please keep your comment within 1,000 characters and relevant to the main topic. We encourage healthy debate, but we don't allow insults or bad language. Anything off topic or unpleasant, we'll remove. Enjoy the conversation! Thank you.

captcha To prevent spam-related comments please enter the characters shown in the 'Captcha' box to the left.

By leaving a comment you accept our terms and conditions.


>