This isn’t democracy

By Bill Bonner Feb 17, 2012

Bill Bonner.

Share with
friends:

Comments (11) Print this article

The trouble with paradise...

“Who would have thought,” said a colleague yesterday. “We got here, what, 15 years ago, there was nothing... nothing.”

“Nothing... but paradise,” we replied.

“Well, now it’s even better. You’re never satisfied. Now we have a paradise with houses... swimming pools... and even a convention centre. It’s a paradise that people can enjoy.”

“I enjoyed it more when we had it all to ourselves,” we countered.

More below. First, let us cast our eyes over the world of finance.

The headlines still focus on Greece. It is broke. Here is Lucas Papademos, describing what an orderly default would mean. In The Telegraph:

"The savings of the citizens would be at risk. The state would be unable to pay salaries, pensions, and cover basic functions, such as hospitals and schools, and ... the country - public and private sector alike - would lose all access to borrowing and liquidity would shrink.

"The living standards of Greeks would collapse. The country would drift into a long spiral of recession, instability, unemployment and prolonged misery. These developments would lead, sooner or later, to exit from the euro."

Sounds good to us! The Greeks have been living beyond their means. Living standards must fall. Best to get on with it.

But the efforts of a whole class of over-paid meddlers have been directed at trying to avoid this outcome. They’ve hesitated, prevaricated, vacillated and generally fornicated up the situation.

They’ve swept so much dirt under the rug that there’s now an Everest in the middle of the room. It can no longer be ignored.

But Greece isn’t the only country to live beyond its means. And the Greeks aren’t the only ones to suffer. In Britain, the economy is holding its own... but only by loading the young with debt in order to continue supporting the old in the style to which they’ve become accustomed.

Here, The New York Times reports:

Perhaps the most debilitating consequence of the euro zone’s economic downturn and its debt-driven austerity crusade has been the soaring rate of youth unemployment. Spain’s jobless rate for people aged 16 to 24 is approaching 50 percent. Greece’s is 48 percent, and Portugal’s and Italy’s, 30 percent. Here in Britain, the rate is 22.3 percent, the highest since such data began being collected in 1992. (The comparable rate for Americans is 18 percent.)

Classified by statisticians as NEETs (not in education, employment or training), they number about 1.3 million, or one of every five 16-to-24-year-olds in the country.

Lower incomes, unemployment, fewer benefits. Get used to it.


DR banner

Receive Bill Bonners free Daily email 'The Daily Reckoning' straight to your inbox


And more thoughts

• We spent a week at our place in Nicaragua... and we wonder why we don’t spend more time here.

“Because life is a struggle,” said our friend. “Here, there’s nothing to struggle against... except your worst enemy, yourself.”

Hmmm...

The climate is benign. No need to fight against the elements. The views are the best in the world. Nature has made this coast her chef d’oeuvre; it would be a sin to complain, ingratitude to ask for more.

But more is just what we can’t help asking for...

The food is delicious. The pace is relaxed. We wake up... the sun shines in the window... Outside, the surf pounds the sand. We take a walk along the beach... often seeing no other human being... splashing our bare feet in the warm water.

Returning up the steps to the house, Tere, our housekeeper has already put breakfast on the table... fresh fruit, coffee, eggs...

Later, we sit on the porch, overlooking the ocean and do our work. No commuting. No traffic. No parking. No snow. No ice. Nothing disturbs our work or our thoughts...

What’s not to like?

“Well... you can’t sit still and enjoy things. You need to look for challenges. And if you can’t get mad at other drivers or God, you’ll have to get mad at yourself.”

Hmmm...

What kind of world is this? We work to make it better and then, when it is nearly perfect, we can’t resist improving it.

... Or making it worse.

• There have always been booms and busts. There were years of good harvests and years of bad ones. The prudent farmer saved some grain just in case.

But in the 20th century real money – gold – was replaced by paper money and ‘just in case’ became ‘just in time’.

Even John Maynard Keynes, the architect of modern government meddling in the economy, suggested that governments should save money so they would have something to spend when the private sector cut back.

But the feds didn’t save. They spent. And when times got tough, they spent even more money. Trouble is, without savings, they had to borrow the money to spend, which means taking it out of the very economy that is short on money already.

The only other option is to print up extra money – in effect, creating it
‘out of thin air.’ But if you could just print ‘money’ and make yourself better off everyone would do it. People are not made richer just by printing up pieces of paper with green ink on them. They get richer by having real purchasing power... and real resources at their command... and by being able to produce goods and services that people want.

• Hillary Clinton calls up Egypt, Syria, Libya, and China to “democratise”. But democracy, as practiced by the US and other developed countries, is a fraud. It is just a way for the insiders to scam money and power from the outsiders, by pretending that the voters are in charge.

Just ask how many taxpayers would vote to spend about $10,000 each on the war against Iraq?

How many would vote to spend $1.60 cents for every dollar in tax revenue?

How many would vote for the latest mortgage deal where homeowners who saved their money and paid their mortgages are forced to make up for those who bought houses recklessly... and then couldn’t make their payments?

How many would vote to bail out Goldman Sachs, Bank of America or Citigroup?

But voters never get a chance to vote on the issues. They vote for candidates financed by insiders, with agendas the outsiders cannot even imagine.

The word ‘democracy’ arose in small, Greek city states, where the voters actually voted on the concrete issues, not just the slippery candidates. Citizens voted to go to war knowing not only that they would have to pay for it... but that they could be killed in the battles themselves. War was a matter of life and death, not just a campaign slogan of a chubby, middle-aged draft-dodger.

The Italian city states practised real democracy too. In 15th century Florence, for example, citizens voted on whether or not to build a cathedral. Then, they voted on what shape it should take.

A scale model was built. Citizens knew what it would look like. They understood how it was built and how much it would cost them. They cast their ballots and took responsibility for the outcome.

American democracy, circa 2012, has no more in common with real democracy than American capitalism has in common with real capitalism. Both are degenerate, corrupt and geriatric.

• Don't miss Bill's next Daily Reckoning. To receive the next article straight into your inbox as soon as he's written it, sign up to the email list here .

Information in The Daily Reckoning is for general information only and is not intended to be relied upon by individual readers in making (or not making) specific investment decisions. Appropriate independent advice should be obtained before making any such decision. Your capital is at risk when you invest in shares - you can lose some or all of your money, so never risk more than you can afford to lose. Always seek personal advice if you are unsure about the suitability of any investment. The Daily Reckoning is an unregulated product published by Fleet Street Publications Ltd. Customer services: 020 7633 3600. Fleet Street Publications Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. http://www.fsa.gov.uk/register/home.do FSA number: 1152 34

Comments (11)

Share with
friends:

Comments

  • 1. Noel Falconer

    (17 February 2012, 05:06PM)  Complain about this comment

    Best yet, Bill!

    So what do we do? What CAN we do?

    Wait. The situation is so rotten it must collapse. Meanwhile, identify and remember the guilty. And vote against every incumbent, whatever his/her party, standing for any office.

  • 2. david hoyle

    (17 February 2012, 10:12PM)  Complain about this comment

    how do outsiders over throw the insiders. are we destined to become surfs, powerless and mightily abused ? or are we already there .
    Does there have to be a bloody revolution, should we Dust off the guillotine.
    these leeches will never let go while they still breath.
    like most couch democrats , the prospect of dis empowering the system seems mountainous. an almost impossible task.. it is world wide, top to bottom corruption.
    what are the solutions ?

  • 3. Anthony Havens

    (18 February 2012, 08:28AM)  Complain about this comment

    Love your articles Bill. Like me, I see that you also like the idea of city states and direct democracy. How can this "golden age" be re-born?
    I have an idea that I'd like to share with you. Can you send me your email? I promise you wont be disappointed. spesbona at adept dot co dot za

  • 4. Boris McDonut

    (18 February 2012, 01:19PM)  Complain about this comment

    Good points Bill. I have said before that Greece is just another former Ottoman province coming to terms with ruling itself and assymilating to the modern world.
    It has been often said that true democracy does not work in states with more than 5 million people. A nation like say Denmark (or dare I say Scotland), where everyone gets at least some reassurance that they can genuinely influence things. That said everyone in Iceland felt they could go and visit the president if they wanted to and that ended up as giant hedge fund to enrich a few.

  • 5. Ellen

    (20 February 2012, 07:57AM)  Complain about this comment

    Great observations on modern democracy. What you described, voting on issues, not candidates, as where democracy started. We only did that in the UK once in 30 years - and that was on whether we'd change how we'd vote for the candidates.

    I have found myself in discussions giving my criticisms of modern democracy and told, more than once, I should be grateful to be able to voice my opinion. That is what democracy is. And I would be shot in other places for doing so!

  • 6. Critic Al Rick

    (20 February 2012, 01:09PM)  Complain about this comment

    But Ellen (as I'm sure you are well aware), Democracy should be about government by the people (for 'people' read 'the majority') for the people, not just freedom of speech or, more particularly, NOT government by Parasites on behalf of Parasites (which is what Democracy has degenerated to).

    The Parasites are killing their host.

  • 7. Ellen

    (20 February 2012, 03:24PM)  Complain about this comment

    @ Critic - You misunderstand me. I don't think the freedom to spout my ineffectual opinions free of the worry of not being executed is worth much. Certainly not the lives that were lost in the various wars that have been fought in the name of democracy. The right of self determination as individuals and as communities/ states is closer to what democracy was supposed to be. But we elect other people to decide what is important to us. Oscar Wilde described it as "The bludgeoning of the people, by the people for the people." Boris McDonuts point that only people living in smaller populations can have any real representation sounds plausible.

  • 8. Boris MacDonut

    (20 February 2012, 06:06PM)  Complain about this comment

    #6 Yikes Al. You suggest the tyranny of the majority. By extension the oppression of the 49% by the 51%.
    Ellen. Outside nice little rich places like Finland or Austria democracy has been hijacked to legitimise and justify a plutocracy or even bankocracy. We are constantly reminded how lucky we are and not to rock the boat while being systematically, right royally, ripped off by the 1% ,their tax haven network and their placemen in politics.

  • 9. Critic Al Rick

    (20 February 2012, 09:08PM)  Complain about this comment

    Boris, Democracy has been so corrupted that depending on which wealth band of 'Parasite' one considers, the tyranny could be the oppression of the 99.999999% by the 0.000001%.

    It was not my suggestion that 51% of the electorate are 'Parasites'.

  • 10. Critic Al Rick

    (20 February 2012, 09:09PM)  Complain about this comment

    Ellen, I was once under the gross misapprehension (i.e. very naive) that the people we elected were endeavouring to work in the best long term interests of the majority.

    I have since learnt that integrity is not synonymous with suits. But at least I don't fear being 'topped' for saying so; well, not yet.

  • 11. george

    (24 February 2012, 06:54PM)  Complain about this comment

    the bigest threat to people from all backgrounds earning a living are the education facist

Leave a comment

This will be the name displayed with your comment.

This helps us verify comments are genuine. It will not be displayed anywhere on the site and is stored confidentially.

Please keep your comment within 1,000 characters and relevant to the main topic. We encourage healthy debate, but we don't allow insults or bad language. Anything off topic or unpleasant, we'll remove. Enjoy the conversation! Thank you.

captcha To prevent spam-related comments please enter the characters shown in the 'Captcha' box to the left.

By leaving a comment you accept our terms and conditions.


FREE - MoneyWeek's daily investment emailJohn Stepek

Our free daily email, Money Morning, is an informative and enjoyable analysis of what's going on in the markets. Written by our Editor, John Stepek, and guest contributors.
Sign up FREE to Money Morning here.

>