Saturday 17th May 2008
moneyweek.com
MoneyWeek logo

The most important financial stories, and how to profit from them

Skip to navigationSkip navigation
travel industry, UK economy

What Alistair Darling could learn from Ryanair

05.02.2008

This genius investor does dizzying levels of research to uncover...Half Price Shares!

This feature is part of our FREE daily Money Morning email. If you'd like to sign up, please click here: Sign up for Money Morning

Irish budget airline Ryanair has a reputation for being straight-talking.

But even so, deputy chief executive Michael Cawley was unusually blunt yesterday when he told investors that “we are gloomy about the next financial year. We feel that recession is imminent – if not already upon us.”

The news battered other airline stocks, inevitably. So is this just Ryanair trying to psyche out its rivals – or is there more to the recession forecast than that?

Ryanair warned yesterday that the 2008/09 financial year will be tough going.

Now, Ryanair boss Michael O’Leary is well known for making big, headline-grabbing statements. He predicted a ‘bloodbath’ in the airline sector a few years ago, which garnered him a lot of press coverage, and he’s no reason to change tack now.

But it would be very surprising if he wasn’t genuinely concerned about what’ll happen this year. For all the protests of tour operators like Tui, the travel market can’t come through a recession unscathed. When people lose their jobs – as happens in a recession – they don’t go on holiday.

The airline reckons that profits could fall by as much as 50% next year, depending on the financial state of consumers, and the price of oil. The group hasn’t hedged its exposure to oil prices, perhaps hoping that if there is a recession, then lower oil prices will partly make up for the slowdown in seat sales.

Given that Ryanair is at the rock-bottom of the budget market, and very canny about finding new ways to charge for things once considered necessities on flights – like bags, for example – I’m sure the airline can cope. I wouldn’t be keen to buy any consumer-facing stocks at the moment, but there are certainly worse companies to be invested in.

When in doubt – blame the US

Someone who could do with taking a leaf out of Ryanair’s book is our Chancellor Alistair Darling. But rather than indulging in any straight-talking, he’s still trying to pin the blame for the UK’s problems on the US. He said yesterday that Britain’s economy was stable and strong, but added the catch-all warning that “these are uncertain times… We do not yet know the full extent of the slowdown affecting the United States.” In other words, if anything else goes wrong, it’s the Americans’ fault. They shouldn’t have loaned all that money to those sub-prime borrowers. But what can you do with them, eh?

Of course, the fact that UK consumers are up to their eyeballs in credit card and mortgage debt, not to mention the government’s distinct lack of prudence when it comes to its own spending, didn’t rate a mention in Mr Darling’s speech. And there’s no need to worry, really – after all, as Mr Darling says: “I believe we will get through this turbulence.”

Well, I’m sure we’ll get through this turbulence too, just as we got through the turbulence of the early 1990s, and the turbulence of the ‘70s, and the turbulence of the Depression. The big worry is not whether or not we get through it – it’s about how long it lasts and how air-sick we all get on the way. And the outlook on that front is not good.

US commercial property is heading for trouble

In the States, for example, credit conditions remain very tight, despite the Federal Reserve’s obvious willingness to do whatever it takes to ‘save’ the economy from recession. The Fed’s latest survey of senior bank loan officers, covering the fourth quarter of 2007, shows that “banks expect to tighten lending criteria even more in the first quarter on nearly every conceivable type of loan to households and businesses,” as Paul Ashworth of Capital Economics put it.

More than 50% of banks are tightening lending standards on prime mortgages, and 80% are tightening up on commercial property loans. “That degree of tightening suggests the commercial real estate sector could endure a more severe downturn than the residential sector is currently suffering,” says Ashworth.

Given that US residential housing is in its worst slump since the Depression, that’s not good news. It looks like there will be plenty of bad news coming from the US in the months ahead – enough to keep Mr Darling fully armed with excuses for our own economy’s woes.

Of course, one thing that Mr Darling will have a tough time blaming on the US is the mess the government has made of the Northern Rock ‘rescue’. You can read our editor Merryn Somerset Webb’s take on the latest developments here: Olivant is out - where now for Northern Rock?

Turning to the wider markets…

(Article continues below)

Advertisement


Enjoying this article? Why not sign up to receive Money Morning FREE every weekday? Just click here: FREE daily Money Morning email


Google shares fall on Microsoft's Yahoo bid

In London, the FTSE 100 ended yesterday just 3 points lower, at 6,026, as the impact of a weak start on Wall Street was offset by M&A-fuelled gains for the likes of Friends Provident and ITV. For a full market report, see: London market close

On the Continent, the Paris CAC-40 was 4 points lower, at 4,973. However, in Frankfurt, the DAX-30 climbed 31 points to close at 7,000, with travel company TUI leading the gainers on what looked like technical buying.

Across the Atlantic, stocks broke a recent rally which saw gains on four days out of five. The Dow Jones fell 108 points to end the day at 12,635, with Google shares down nearly 4% on news of Microsoft's bid for Yahoo. The S&P 500 was 14 points lower, at 1,380. And the tech-rich Nasdaq was down 30 points, at 2,382.

In Asia, stock closed lower. The Japanese Nikkei was down 114 points at 13,745 and the Hong Kong Hang Seng was 223 points lower, at 24,808.

Crude oil futures had fallen back to $89.47 this morning and Brent spot was at $90.07 in London.

Platinum hits new record high

Platinum hit a fresh all-time high of $1,809 today as South African power cuts continued to hinder supply. Spot gold had risen to $895.60 from yesterday's two-week low of $891.65. And silver had fallen to $16.53.

In the currency markets, the pound was at 1.9693 against the dollar and 1.3378 against the euro. And the dollar was at 0.6792 against the euro and 211.20 against the Japanese yen

And in London this morning, oil giant BP announced a 53% rise in Q4 net income to $4.4bn, below analysts' estimates. Despite oil hitting nearly $100 a barrel, problems at the company's US refineries along with higher-than-expected have put a dent in the company's income

Our recommended articles for today...

Are these investments as 'safe' as the salesmen claim?
- It looks as though a bear market could be with us for some time, so what does the financial services industry do: encourage us to continue to buy stocks through special new products. But are either their cautious managed funds or guaranteed equity bonds a safe haven for your money? Find out what Merryn Somerset Webb thinks here: Are these investments as 'safe' as the salesmen claim?

How the Fed just made this crisis a whole lot worse
- The Fed's rate cuts and $156bn fiscal stimulus package may have reduced the risk of near-term economic downturn, but has increased the scale of a long-term crisis. Jeremy Batstone looks at why the dollar will be key to the future of the US economy: How the Fed just made this crisis a whole lot worse



FREE! For all our latest advice on making profitable investments, claim your 3-week FREE trial of the MoneyWeek website and magazine now.
FREE! MoneyWeek’s daily investment email. A quick, useful and entertaining round-up of the latest investment news, sent to your inbox first thing every morning.To sign up to our “Money Morning” email for FREE, just click here.
Free! Our daily email
Free Daily Email sign up
Money Morning is the FREE daily email from MoneyWeek – a punchy round-up of the latest investment news and profit opportunities. DON’T MISS IT!
New to MoneyWeek? Editor Merryn Somerset Webb explains what we do

 

FTSE 100 - 17 May 08